The Penny’s Big Exit: How It’s Changing Coin Collecting

In 2025, the penny is making headlines—not for its value, but for its vanishing act. With production costs soaring and digital payment systems expanding, the humble one-cent coin is quickly becoming obsolete. But here’s the kicker: this small change is causing a big ripple across the collecting community.

As longtime coin enthusiasts know, even the tiniest denomination can leave a lasting impression. At Coins Online, we’ve guided collectors through every currency transition since 1989—and this one is worth watching.

Whether you’re holding on to copper relics or preparing to diversify your collection, understanding the penny’s downfall can help you collect with confidence.

The Penny Is Disappearing—Here’s Why

1. It Costs More to Make Than It’s Worth

Since 2006, it has cost the U.S. Mint more than one cent to mint a penny. In fact, each one costs over 2.5 cents to produce—an inefficiency called “negative seigniorage.” The Treasury has debated discontinuing it for years, and now, with rising inflation and metal costs, the penny’s days are clearly numbered.

This shift doesn’t just affect your spare change—it signals a broader rethinking of small-denomination coinage.

2. Rounding Rules Are Gaining Ground

As countries like Canada and Australia have already done, U.S. businesses may start rounding cash totals to the nearest five cents. That doesn’t affect electronic payments—but it does make the penny functionally useless in most cash transactions. Here’s context on it from the US Government.

Collectors are already noticing a behavioral shift: fewer pennies in circulation means fewer finds in pocket change. It’s not just economic—it’s cultural, this is why penny coin collecting is getting renewed attention.

3. It’s Fueling the Cashless Movement

The penny’s decline is part of a larger push toward digital transactions. Systems like FedNow and the potential digital dollar make physical cash less relevant for everyday purchases. While not a threat to collectible coins, this transition affects how people perceive value.

Smart collectors will recognize this moment as a pivot point: your physical collection isn’t obsolete—it’s becoming more exclusive.

What It Means for Collectors

1. Scarcity Creates Opportunity

As production stops, existing pennies—especially pre-1982 copper cents—could gain value due to their metal content and limited supply. High-grade Lincoln Wheat pennies and error coins might also see increased interest.

Coins Online recommends examining your penny collection for:

• Copper content (pre-1982 coins)
• Rare mintmarks (like the 1909-S VDB)
• Graded condition (seek MS65 or higher for legacy appeal)

Explore our curated Penny Collection – www.coinsonline.com/product-category/us-coins/cents

2. Shifting Focus to New Denominations

With the penny phasing out, collectors are turning their attention to nickels, dimes, and commemorative issues. Series like the Jefferson Nickel or Mercury Dime are gaining popularity as collectors look to build sets that reflect current change.

Check out U.S. dimes from the 20th century

3. Legacy Collecting in a Digital Age

The evolution of currency doesn’t mean the end of physical collecting—it means it’s entering a new chapter. From blockchain-based authenticity to digital inventory tools, the next generation of collectors will blend tradition with tech.

Coins Online continues to prioritize transparency with full grading details, trusted partnerships, and clear provenance—so you can collect confidently, whether online or in hand.

Featured Product: Wheat Cents – Random (500 Count Bag)

Wheat Cents 5000-Count Bag of common dates in circulated condition. Affordable bulk purchase for collectors, hobbyists, and educators.

• $59.99
  Add to cart

Final Thoughts: Every Exit Is an Entry Point

The penny may be on its way out, but for collectors, that just opens the door to new possibilities. From scarcity-driven value to a renewed focus on higher denominations, now is the time to rethink your collecting strategy.

Ready to reimagine your collection in a post-penny world?

Explore our site and browse by category, or download our Coin Collecting Guide for deeper insights